From a Farther Room

Words and Pictures

Reading in a post-Potter world: some suggestions

My sister-in-law asked the other day for some post-Potter recommendations; my niece plowed through the last Harry Potter tome in two days, and hasn’t found a replacement yet for the Potter books. I wasn’t able to get into the first Harry book–I just didn’t care for the writing–but I was able to rattle off a short list of my favorite fantasy series from my pre-teen reading. No doubt there are newer series out there that are just as good as these trusty-rusty books; if anyone has any suggestions, please pass them along.

Harry Potter has been a mixed blessing, it seems, for YA literature: he’s brought a lot of attention to a class of books that are often overlooked, but his shadow is a bit too long.

A YA tale of magic that I haven’t read yet, but that intrigues me, is the His Dark Materials series by Philip Pullman: The Golden Compass, The Subtle Knife, and The Amber Spyglass. And a menacing little tale I’d recommend only to children of a stern constitution is Neil Gaiman’s Coraline, which features a dark parallel world and terrible things in the cellar. While I do enjoy frightening children–I pick my candy-distribution outfit for Hallowe’en around whether it will make our neighbor Pat’s knees knock–I also believe in giving fair warning . . .

Bookmark and Share:
Posted by Michael Hartford | Aug 26, '07 | Talking of Michelangelo, Till human voices wake us |


2 comments en “Reading in a post-Potter world: some suggestions”

  1. Imani says:


    I second the Pullman recommendation and would add Jonathan Stroud’s “Bartimaeus Trilogy”. It’s also set in Britain, in an unspecified time, and serves quite a sophisticated (or cynical, rather?) take on its magical world. The female protagonist who shows up in the second book is not unlike Harry in her unwavering dedication to all things honourable, but the boy is very much the sort who would have ended up in Slytherin. His journey is therefore a far more interesting one to watch and that, among other reasons, make it superior to the Harry Potter series in significant ways.

    It’s also *hilarious*.

  2. Michael Hartford says:


    Thanks for the tip, Imani; I’d never heard of the Bartimaeus Trilogy, but a little scouting has bumped it up the list. The character development you describe is certainly something that seemed lacking in the Potter books: if the hero starts off at least mildly heroic, there’s not much to keep one turning the pages. I should add T.H. White’s “Sword in the Stone” series to the list for that reason: Wart was an unpleasant little boy at the start.

    My two young readers just turned six, so I’ve got some time to catch up on the developments in this genre. They’re a good excuse to browse the YA shelves at the library without looking too much like a creepy old man…



Leave a comment

Photoblogs.org VFXY Photos Photoblog AwardsCool Photoblogs Photo Blog Directory